Sixth National Conference on Quality Health Care for Culturally Diverse Populations: Poster Presentations A QI Strategy to Address Disparities and Cultural Competence

Poster Session I Poster Presentations (Group I)

A QI Strategy to Address Disparities and Cultural Competence
Monday, September 22, 2008: 1:00 PM-7:30 PM, Minn Marriott, 4th Floor - Atrium
Description
Our multi-site HIV clinical care network had concerns about the cultural competence of our program and its impact on patient care. We saw worrisome indications of disparities in outcomes among our patients. Time-consuming conventional cultural competence trainings were provided, but we had doubts that these were having an impact on health outcomes—and evaluation of the impact of training on outcomes was fuzzy at best.
Staff and leadership were interested in an approach to cultural competence improvement that was better integrated into daily work and more sustainable. We decided to use QI methods to approach improving disparities and cultural competence. QI processes emphasize a system-wide approach, use of multidisciplinary teams, steady incremental change, bottom-up problem solving, and accountability without finger-pointing. We found that most QI tools and measures addressing cultural competence were designed for hospitals and health systems, not for individual clinics and practices. Given the lack of “off the shelf” resources, we researched our own set of promising performance improvements and measures to adopt in our community health center-based project. Through our QI system we have monitored these measures quarterly along with our other quality improvement measures. 
In this session, we will review our experiences and share performance measures and improvement ideas that we have adopted in our program.  An interactive session at the end will have participants select measures and improvement ideas to try in their own work sites.

Successes

  • We selected several QI performance measures that we will be tracking for the next two years to see if we are narrowing racial and ethnic gaps in care.
  • CQI committee chose a cultural proficiency assessment tool that best fit the agencies in our network, and had a mixed group of providers, leaders and line staff complete them.
  • Agencies chose one improvement strategy to test around cultural competence and discussed the results at quarterly QI team meetings.
  • Agencies disseminated a uniform patient satisfaction survey which contained cultural competence questions that were approved by the consumer task force.
Challenges
  • Obtaining accurate race/ethnicity data was difficult. Discovered that data was usually obtained by observation.
  • Developing a training that would be useful and engaging for leaders, providers and line staff.
  • Obtaining impact data to see whether we can use this mechanism to make real progress on reducing disparities.
Lessons Learned
  • Having leadership and QI team working together is key. Leadership will be able to push cultural competence initiative through QI methods and staff will feel QI is more core to their work, not picayune, since it is taking on the big issues. This has helped boost the morale around the detail of QI work.
  • Use consumer input in areas such as patient satisfaction surveys and health belief inventories.
  • Integration of cultural competence work into existing quality improvement priorities and processes can be an efficient and successful way to make progress toward disparity reduction.

Presentation Information:

Program: Poster Presentations
Primary Category: Culturally Competent Care
Subtopics: Quality improvement

Region Addressed by Presentation: US - California
Organization: Clinic
Population/Demographic: Low income chronic illness
Keywords: Organizational plans and policies, Practical strategies


Website: http://www.ihi.org/IHI/Topics/HIVAIDS/HIVDiseaseGeneral/Tools/AGuidetoAddressingCulturalCompetenceQIinHIVCare.htm

Hela Issaq, MPH , HIV ACCESS & The Family Care Network, Alameda, CA
    QI Project Manager
    HIV ACCESS & The Family Care Network
    1320 Harbor Bay Parkway Ste 250
    Alameda CA, USA 94502

    Phone: (510) 769-2242
    Email Address: helai@alamedahealthconsortium.org

    Biographical Sketch:
    Hela Issaq is the Quality Improvement Project Manager for HIV ACCESS and The Family Care Network in Alameda County. She works with several primary care and support services sites to improve services through conducting client quality feedback sessions, patient satisfaction surveys, as well as measuring performance data. As a HRET Cultural Competence Leadership Fellow, she is currently focusing on how use quality improvement methods to help address health disparities issues in both networks. She is also a co-author of guide published through the National Quality Center on this subject.

Kathleen Clanon, MD , HIV ACCESS & The Family Care Network, Oakland, CA
    Medical Director
    HIV ACCESS & The Family Care Network
    614 Grand Avenue
    Suite 400
    Oakland CA, USA 94610

    Phone: (510) 612-5548
    Email Address: kclanon@jba-cht.com

    Biographical Sketch:
    Dr. Clanon is an internist specializing in the care of people with HIV. She practices at Alameda County Medical Center in Oakland, and is the Medical Director of HIV ACCESS, a network of primary care sites serving people with HIV. She has special interests in the reduction of health disparities and in quality improvement in HIV programs. She has published a guide on this topic through the National Quality Center. She works as a consultant for the National Quality Center and the HIVQUAL Project. Dr. Clanon is an Associate Professor of Clinical Medicine at UCSF and Clinical Director of the Pacific AIDS Education and Training Center, as well as founding Board Chair of the Community Institute for Healthcare Equity.

Nancy Halloran, MPH , Health Equity Partnership & Community Institute for Healthcare Equity, Oakland, CA
    Program Developer
    Health Equity Partnership & Community Institute for Healthcare Equity
    614 Grand Ave, Suite 400
    Oakland CA, USA 94610

    Phone: 510-847-3833
    Email Address: nshalloran@sonic.net

    Biographical Sketch:
    Nancy Halloran has worked for more than twenty years applying her professional skills to community-based organizational development and program planning, primarily in the field of HIV care. Her work experience ranges from leadership of grass-roots campaign organizations to administration of a $4 million HIV services program in a public health clinic in Oakland, California to independent consultant and principal of the Health Equity Partnership. Her community leadership roles have included chair of the East Bay AIDS Response Organization (1988), founding chair of the Family Care Network (Ryan White Title IV) Executive Committee (1995-97), and chair of the Oakland EMA Planning Council (1998); she currently serves as Officer of the Board of the newly-established Community Institute for Healthcare Equity.

Patricia Calloway, RN, PHN , Alameda County Department of Public Health, Oakland, CA
    QM Coordinator
    Alameda County Department of Public Health
    1000 Broadway Ste 5000
    Oakland CA, USA 94612

    Phone: 510-393-9473
    Email Address: Patricia.Calloway@acgov.org

    Biographical Sketch:
    Patricia has worked as a Labor and Delivery nurse for many years and has been a nurse in the Public Health Department for over a decade. She is currently completing the HRET Cultural Competence Leadership Fellowship where she has been using her QI expertise to improve cultural competence in agencies that serve HIV patients.